You might want to sit down for this.
Our selection of pies is extensive, but we're sure you'll find your favorite in no time.
9-inch Pies
Our 9-inch pies are great for sharing between a couple people. You can get about 6-8 slices from this pie, depending what a slice means to you.
Baby Pies
This 6-inch pie is perfect for treating yourself. With only 1.5-2 slices, a Baby Pie doesn’t even cheat your new diet.
Tarts
These petite tarts are the smallest treats we offer in our shop. They’re only 3-inches and cute as can be!
Pot Pies & Quiche
Our savory pie selections go from freezer to oven in under 30 seconds, making you the hero of your dinner table. Crafted completely from scratch, our pot pies and quiche make the perfect meal!
Flavors
FruiT
American Apple (SF | DF) (traditional lattice top)
Blackberry (SF | DF)
Blueberry (SF | DF)
Blueberry Streusel (brown sugar, butter, oat crumble topping with homemade streusel)
Caramel Apple (brown sugar/butter crumble topping with homemade caramel sauce)
Cherry (SF | DF)
Cherry Crisp (brown sugar, butter, oat crumble topping)
Cherry Custard
Drunken Apple (DF) (a fun take on American Apple pie with a heavy shot of bourbon)
Dutch Apple (brown sugar/butter crumble topping)
Gooseberry (SF | DF)
Mixed Berry (blueberry, blackberry, raspberry with lattice) (SF | DF)
Mixed Berry Crumble (blueberry, blackberry, raspberry with brown sugar/butter/oat topping)
Old Fashioned Peach (SF | DF)
Old Fashioned Raisin
Peach Praline (brown sugar/butter/pecan crumble topping)
Peach Raspberry (SF | DF)
Rhubarb (SF | DF)
Strawberry Rhubarb (SF | DF)
Summer Berry Crumble (blueberry, blackberry, raspberry, strawberry with brown sugar/butter/oat topping)
Sweet Potato (SF/DF)
Cream
Almond Joy *(SF) (chocolate cream with shredded coconut and almond extract)
Almond Rum Raspberry (vanilla cream base with almond extract, rum, fresh raspberries in the filling and in the whipped cream)
Banana Cream * (SF)
Banoffee (layer of caramel sauce, fresh bananas, traditional vanilla cream filling, with homemade whipped cream and caramel drizzle)
Brown Butter Chess
Chocolate Cream * (SF)
Chocolate Banana * (SF)
Chocolate Chess
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Chocolate Peanut Butter (GF)
Coconut Cream * (SF)
Coconut Banana Cream* (SF)
Egg Custard
French Silk (GF)
Key Lime (GF)
Lemon Cream * (GF)
Lemon Raspberry (GF)
Peanut Butter (GF)
Peanut Butter & Jelly (GF)
Pumpkin (GF) (SF)
Pumpkin Bourbon (GF)
Pumpkin Chiffon (GF)
Raisin Cream (baked with a meringue topping, please give advanced notice if you prefer homemade whipped cream)
Raspberry Key Lime (GF)
Vanilla Cream *(SF)
White Chocolate Raspberry (GF)
White Chocolate Strawberry (GF)
* Give advanced notice if you’d like a meringue topping rather than whipped topping.
Nut
Butterscotch Bourbon Pecan
Chocolate Bourbon Pecan
Southern Pecan (GF)
German Chocolate (GF)
Savory
Pot Pie – Pot Roast (slow roasted pot roast, potatoes, peas, carrots, and onions)
Pot Pie – Roasted Chicken (shredded chicken, peas, carrots, and onions)
Pot Pie - Southwestern Chicken (shredded chicken, black beans, roasted corn, onions, and cheese)
Pot Pie - Buffalo Chicken (shredded chicken, Frank’s Red Hot, cream cheese, and ranch dressing)
Quiche - Bacon Cheddar
Quiche - Vegetable (spinach, mushroom, and onion)
Quiche - Broccoli Cheddar
Quiche - Sausage
(GF) = Available in gluten-free (additional charge)
(SF) = Available in sugar-free (additional charge)
(DF) = Available in dairy-free (additional charge)
Order Now!
Featured Pies
White Chocolate Strawberry
Say hello to this fluffy cloud of strawberry whipped cream with a foundation of dense white chocolate cheesecake.
These delicious layers meet in the middle with a sweet spread of baked strawberries. See what Food Network was talking about when they named this pie one of the Best Pies in America.
Mixed Berry
This sweet berry concoction can make the most serious city slicker crave an afternoon on a blueberry farm.
Before you indulge in this scrumptious fruit pie, don't forget to take a picture of the beautiful lattice of Peggy Jean's pie crust. Once you take a bite, you'll understand why our pie crust recipe is too darn good to share. Buy your pie now.
Chocolate Bourbon Pecan
With chocolate, bourbon, and pecan in one pie— what's not to love?
The mix of a crunchy nut topping with a smooth chocolate center is enough to have you thinking about this pie months after your last bite. The hints of bourbon round out this decadent treat and move it from snack level to full-blown dessert. Drop by the shop and see for yourself!