Frequently Asked Questions

+ Do you sell jeans there?

No...We tried to sell jeans but we couldn't stop getting flour all over them. So we stuck to pies. Thanks for reminding us of the good ole days, though!

+ Can I just come in and buy pie?

Yes! We make over 20 flavors in two sizes each and every day. We stock the store for variety. We recommend ordering ahead if you have a specific flavor in a specific size you want, but we always start the day with a stocked store. We do tend to sell out toward the end of the day, so if you want to be sure a pie has your name on it, order by 5p the day before you want ot pick it up. Otherwise, we will have many flavors for you to choose from when you visit.

+ Can I visit the shop?

Absolutely! We encourage you and stop by and indulge in pie. Please note that we do not offer seating, but we do have forks and napkins to go with your pie! We’re open Monday-Friday 10:00am-6:00pm and Saturday 10:00am-5pm. Learn more.

+ Do you offer seating?

We do not. Never say never, but right now you’ll have to buy your pie on a grab-and-go basis. If you’re worried about a wait you can pre-order your pie! Check out our pre-order FAQs.

+ Do you offer gift cards?

Yes! You may purchase gift cards (in any denomination) at either of our two locations in Columbia, MO. Our gift cards make perfect gifts and never expire!

+ What can you ship?

At this time we ship six-packs of Jelly Jar Pies and four packs of our three-inch tarts. (Don’t be confused by the name, these sweet pies have nothing to do with jelly…they are made-from-scratch-with-a-ton-of-love tiny pies and baked into a four-ounce canning jar.) Right now, we don’t ship cream pies. Our fruit and nut pies ship deliciously and withstand a variety of temperatures because they are canned.

+ Where can you ship?

You can ship Peggy Jean's from coast to coast! Check out our delivery page.

+ What comes with a package of Jelly Jar Pies?

Each package of six Jelly Jar Pies arrives on your doorstep via two-day UPS delivery. Six tiny forks are included and tied with a ribbon so you don't have to delay pie time any longer!

+ When can I expect my pie?

We ship every Tuesday. You MUST order by 6pm CST on Monday in order to be included in the next day's shipment. If you order after 6pm CST on Monday, you will be included in the next week's shipping order, so don't delay!z

+ Why haven't I received my pie?

Peggy Jean’s can’t guarantee the delivery of your package. Sometimes life happens, and surprises like bad weather can delay the arrival of your package.  Peggy Jean’s Pies can’t refund any part of your order due to shipping delays. To lessent the worry of shipping delays, make sure to include a phone number for the lucky person who’s getting these pies.

+ How does the pie end up on my doorstep?

UPS will deliver the pies to your doorstep but they won't need a signature. So, make sure someone is home on Thursday afternoon/evening to pick up your pies from the front step.

+ Do you make all types of pie every day?

Sadly not. That’s so many pies that we would either have to be robots or just way less friendly. We make over 20 different flavors each day depending on how what the mood of our kitchen is. If you’re hankering for a specific flavor- fear not! You can pre-order a pie so that you can have whatever pie flavor your lil heart desires.

+ Can I have your recipes?

Girl, no! Would you ask Google for their algorithm? I certainly hope not. Our family secret is in the proportions of the pie dough ingredients and it’s not written down anywhere.

+ Do you bake everything yourselves?

Heck yeah we do. Every single stinkin’ thing from scratch, every single day. And whatever doesn’t sell goes for half price the next morning. Check out what’s baking at Peggy’s Jeans on our Pie Menu.

+ Can I bring you ingredients to bake with?

No, sorry. We've got our own thing going over at Peggy Jean's kitchen. If you're looking for something specific in your pie you can check out our Pie Menu or even pre-order a pie.

+ Do you sell slices or do I have to buy the whole pie?

We only sell whole pies but if you're trying to find the loophole in your new diet we sell Baby Pies! Baby Pies are 6" pies and the perfect thing for anyone trying to restrain themselves from scarfing down a whole pie.

+ What sizes of pie do you have?

You can buy a 6" Baby Pie or a 9" pie every day. If you're looking for a 3" Tart or a Jelly Jar Pie, you need to put in a special order. Check out the pre-order FAQs.

+ Do you sell out?

Yes! I don't know if you've heard, but people love pie. If you want something specific, you can call and pre-order. And if we don't sell out, those pies will be half-off the next day.

+ What if I want to bake my pie at home?

You're in luck! We do offer the option to pre-order a frozen and unbaked pie. We will make it fresh for you in our famous PJP kitchens, freeze it, and you'll take it home and bake it! No worries...we include instructions! As a bonus, your house is going to smell AHHHHMAZING!

+ What if I want to buy, like, a lot of pie?

Then a lot of pie you shall have! Everyone has different ideas on what large orders look like, so contact us at hello@pjpies.com for more information. Check out the Pie Menu to see which flavor(s) you want!

+ Do you do weddings?

Yes! First off, congratulations on your big day. Second, we would be happy to bake your wedding pie.
We've catered weddings of all sizes and all aesthetics, so we are always happy to work with you to find the perfect pie solution!

+ How many guests can you serve?

The more, the merrier! We have served weddings of 3,000 before and they've ranged from super formal to a barnyard bash. So no matter the size or the theme of your wedding-we'll be there.

+ Can I come in and taste wedding pies?

We encourage it! Inquire about a pie tasting on our weddings page.